Document Everything Carefully
Create a dedicated file with installation contracts, warranty documents, repair records, and high-resolution photos. The more organized your proof of roof history, the better your chances during a claim review.
Invest in Professional Inspections
Regular roofing inspections help detect issues early, provide written assessments, and carry weight with insurers. Third-party documentation strengthens your case significantly.
Demonstrate Proactive Maintenance
Insurers reward active upkeep. Keep records of gutter cleanings, timely repairs, sealant applications, and maintenance contracts — it’s a simple way to show you’ve preserved the roof’s integrity.
Shop Insurance Carriers Strategically
Some insurers penalize age more than others. Look for carriers that work with older homes, offer bundling discounts, or rely on trusted input from roofing contractors familiar with roof-insurance dynamics.
What You Can Do if Coverage Is Denied
Even if your claim is denied or limited, you still have options:
- Request a detailed inspection report and second opinion.
- Show proof of proactive maintenance that extends roof life.
- Appeal the decision with more documentation or negotiate terms.
- Explore specialized insurance products or consider preventive roof replacement if your roof is approaching failure.
Actual Cash Value (ACV)
ACV is the depreciated value of your roof — insurers deduct for age and wear.
You can expect:
- 50-70 percent depreciation
- Significant out-of-pocket costs
- “Like kind” material restrictions
Example: $15,000 roof → $5,000 payout → $10,000 owed by homeowner
Replacement Cost Value (RCV)
RCV pays full replacement cost for similar-quality materials.
Benefits include:
- No depreciation deductions
- Freedom to use modern equivalents
- Minimal cost beyond deductible
Condition-Based Clues
- Patchwork repairs or curled shingle edges
- Missing or damaged shingles
- Granule buildup in gutters
Insurance Behavior Clues
- Unexpected inspection requirements
- Sharp premium increases at renewal
- Subtle changes to your policy language
You’ve done everything right — maintained your roof, fixed small issues, and survived decades of weather. Your insurer is pulling back coverage now that it’s 20 years old. Why?
Let’s pull back the curtain on what’s happening when your roof turns 20, and show you how to work the insurance restoration process in your favor.
Why 20 Years Becomes the Insurance "Danger Zone"
Twenty years isn’t random — it’s the industry’s risk tipping point. Most roofing materials hit the end of their actuarial lifespan around this time, and insurers start to see your roof as a liability.
Here’s what often changes at the 20-year mark:
- Coverage downgrade: Shift from Replacement Cost Value (RCV) to Actual Cash Value (ACV).
- Inspection requirements: Some insurers require proof that your roof is still in good condition.
- Claim restrictions: Older roofs often trigger denials, even for storm-related damage.
- Premium increases: Age = risk = higher cost to you.
How Insurers View Different Roofing Materials
Not all roofs are equal in the eyes of insurance. Roof material type largely impacts whether you’ll be covered at 20 years.
Insurance Coverage by Material
Tip: Keep installation and maintenance records — they often make the difference in claim approvals.
Will Insurance Cover a 20-Year-Old Roof in Texas?
Homeowners in Texas face some of the nation’s toughest insurance scrutiny regarding aging roofs. The state’s severe weather creates elevated risk levels that impact how insurers write, renew, or deny policies.
- Hail damage history: Texas leads the country in hail-related insurance claims. Insurers often require impact-resistant materials to maintain full coverage for older roofs.
- Wind load requirements: In Gulf Coast areas, older roofs may no longer meet updated structural standards, making them harder to insure without upgrades.
- Local carrier flexibility: Some Texas-based insurers better understand regional weather risks and may offer more favorable terms to homeowners with documented maintenance.
Broader Regional Risk Factors
Texas isn’t the only state where location alters coverage. Insurers evaluate risks based on your area’s climate patterns and regulatory environment:
Weather-Based Considerations
- High-wind zones: Stricter age limits apply due to frequent storm-related damage.
- Hail-prone regions: Older roof materials are scrutinized more closely.
- Hurricane zones: Coastal areas often require reinforced materials and fasteners.
- Snow load areas: Structural aging becomes a concern under heavy accumulation.
Local Code and Policy Constraints
- Updated building codes: Older roofs may not conform to current code, reducing insurability.
- Material and method standards: Some policies require modern roofing systems or upgraded materials.
- Inspection requirements: Certain municipalities enforce periodic roof inspections before renewals or claims.
What Is the Actual Cash Value of a 20-Year-Old Roof?
You might assume your insurance will pay to replace your roof fully, until you learn about ACV. Understanding how ACV differs from RCV is essential to avoid unexpected expenses and make informed decisions when filing a claim.
Red Flags That Signal Coverage Problems
Certain indicators suggest your 20-year-old roof might face coverage challenges. Keep the following in mind:
How to Protect Your Roof Coverage — Before and After the Claim
Whether preparing proactively or dealing with a denied claim, these steps can help you take control of your roof coverage.
Don't settle for less just because your roof hit the 20-year mark. Our team has outlined these proven strategies to help you strengthen your case, improve your policy terms, and protect your home more effectively.
When Roof Replacement Is the Smarter Investment
Around the 20-year mark, insurance providers start viewing your roof as a risk, not a safeguard. In many cases, full replacement makes more financial sense than ongoing repairs.
- Full coverage restoration: New roofs qualify for complete replacement coverage.
- Energy efficiency gains: Modern materials reduce utility costs significantly.
- Property value increase: New roofs boost home values and marketability.
- Cost-benefit factors: Weigh current condition, potential claims, and long-term savings.
Still Covered — or at Risk?
When your roof turns 20, insurance companies stop seeing protection and start seeing risk. But that doesn’t mean you're out of options. This process isn’t something you need to endure alone. At Built to Last Roofing, our seasoned team can help ensure your roof is an asset to your home.
Call us or schedule a consultation before a denied claim catches you off guard. We’ll help you stay protected, not just insured.
Worried About Your Roof's Insurance Coverage?
Many homeowners don’t realize their coverage changed — until a claim gets denied.
Let our Built to Last Roofing team review your roof and policy before it costs you thousands.
FAQ
Can I get full coverage on a 20-year-old roof?
Yes, if your roof has premium materials and you’ve documented maintenance. Insurers may keep you on RCV if you prove that your roof’s condition and lifespan are strong.
Why did my policy change without notice?
Unfortunately, insurers often change roof coverage at renewal without alerting homeowners. You may only notice the change when you file a claim or see your rate increase.
How do I know if I’m on ACV now?
Look for policy terms like actual cash value or depreciation clauses. Are you unsure about your coverage? Built to Last Roofing can help review your policy and identify potential gaps during a free consultation.
Will impact-resistant shingles improve my coverage?
Yes, especially in Texas. These shingles may qualify you for discounts, RCV eligibility, or extended protection under high-risk weather conditions.
Should I switch insurers to keep coverage?
Switching may help, but it’s not always the best path. New insurers might require inspections or raise flags impacting your overall home policy.
Recent Posts
What Is the Average Cost of Roof Replacement in San Antonio, Texas?
Planning a roof replacement in San Antonio? Learn the average costs you can expect and budget effectively with Built to Last Roofing!
How Much Does Roof Repair Cost in Plano, TX?
Wondering about roof repair costs in Plano, Texas? Built to Last Roofing breaks down average prices, factors affecting cost, and how to budget for your repair.
How Many Shingles Do You Need: Roofing Material Calculator
Use the Built to Last Roofing calculator to estimate your roofing material needs accurately.🔩 Ask our roofing experts if you have any questions. Free estimates!